COVID-19: Did lockdown help or hinder our creativity?

New Normal Health
All data and statistics are based on publicly available data at the time of publication. Some information may be out of date. Visit our coronavirus hub for the most recent information on COVID-19.
coronavirus hub
Share on Pinterest
The American Psychological Association defines “creativity” as “the ability to produce or develop original work, theories, techniques, or thoughts.”
creativity
While this obviously applies to artistry, it can apply equally to everyday activities in which one takes existing elements and creates something new—such as using the ingredients of sourdough bread to make the pandemic food staple.
A new study from the Paris Brain Institute at Sorbonne University decided to investigate the effect the first COVID-19 lockdown had on creativity.
Paris Brain Institute
To explore its impact, they conducted a French-language online survey to learn more about people’s experiences with creativity during this first lockdown in France. The study’s authors hoped to reconcile the seeming paradox of heightened creativity during a time of unusual stress.
stress
The study’s 343 participants said they were, on average, more creative during the lockdown than during the period before.
The findings were published in the journal Frontiers in Psychology.
Frontiers in Psychology
What were people doing in lockdown?
In addition to listing self-perceived creativity changes, or subjective creativity change (SCC), as described above, the researchers presented participants with an inventory of 28 creative activities based on existing items often used by research psychologists, including the Inventory of Creative Activities and Achievements (ICAA). These included painting, cooking, sewing, gardening, writing, and decorating, among others.
Inventory of Creative Activities and Achievements (ICAA)
Respondents were asked if they engaged in these activities more or less during the lockdown, how often, and why they did or didn’t.
The top five creative activities in which the study’s respondents said they engaged in were cooking, sports and dance programs, self-help programs, and gardening.
The researchers also inquired about pandemic obstacles that had to be overcome. There was no clear indication that a higher number of obstacles hindered creativity.
The extent of obstacles encountered was high for individuals who were more creative as well as for those who were less so.
“The minute you set constraints, now the creative mind gets to work on how do I achieve the goal, conditional on these constraints?” said Dr. Ajay Agrawal, University of Toronto, on the Disruptors podcast.
Dr. Ajay Agrawal
Disruptors
The two greatest factors in whether a person’s level of creativity during the lockdown rose or fell were emotional or affective changes and—to a slightly lesser degree—whether the pandemic gave them more free time.
The degree to which an individual exhibits openness—one of the Big Five personality traits—followed behind as a significant factor. The authors chose openness because this is the personality trait most associated with creativity.
Big Five personality traits
openness
The role of emotion in creavity
According to the study, previous research suggests that a positive mood is correlated to creative activity, although there is still some debate.
positive mood
The authors of the study confirmed that participants’ affective states aligned with SCC. The descriptors they asked participants about “included anxiety and stress, motivation, psychological pressure, mood, and to a lower extent, loneliness and physical constraints.”
anxiety
Researchers found a link between positive mood and creativity, and one between negative affective states and less creativity.
Co-first author of the study Dr. Alizée Lopez-Persem, suggests:
Dr. Alizée Lopez-Persem
suggests
“There is some evidence in the scientific literature that you need to feel good to be creative, while other evidence points the other way. Also, it is not known in which direction this process takes place: do we feel good because we are creative, or does being creative make us happier?”
“Here, one of our analyses suggests that creative expression enabled individuals to better manage their negative emotions linked to confinement and therefore to feel better during this difficult period.”— Dr. Alizée Lopez-Persem
Having more free time
The elimination of commuting returned hours to many people, leaving them with more free time, although this was not likely true for everyone. Parents, for example, may have had less free time with children confined at home all day.
Participants were asked about how many hours they worked, how much free time, and how much personal space they had.
The authors came to this conclusion: “An increase in free time was linked to higher creativity change.”
Being open to new experiences
Openness is defined by Psychology Today:
Psychology Today
“Openness to experience, or simply openness, is a basic personality trait denoting receptivity to new ideas and new experiences.”
The study’s survey included 11 questions regarding openness, and found that this trait, too, exhibited a correlation to the SCC results. However, as Dr. Emmanuelle Volle, co-author of the study told Medical News Today:
Dr. Emmanuelle Volle
“Openness indeed correlated with our subjective creativity change score, indicating that openness played a role in the way people thought their creativity changed during the lockdown. It also correlated with the rated creativity of the activities participants performed during this period.”
“However, it did not really draw a line [between being creative or not] because even after correcting for Openness, our creativity change score was still positive, and similarly correlated with free time and affective factors. In other words, free time and affective factors were found related to subjective creativity changes ‘beyond’ Openness,” he said.